Showing posts with label Let's Talk. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Let's Talk. Show all posts

Friday, April 1, 2011

Let's Talk: Photoshop



So I woke up this morning, took care of some errands, and decided to spend a few leisurely moments on the Internet. I often check out what's at Jezebel (you bet I've got the old layout activated), and today one of the posts was about more Photoshop mishaps over at Ann Taylor's website.

Now there's the obvious mistake: the missing arm. Admittedly, I probably wouldn't notice it, at least at first, as I browsed the online catalog, but a missing arm is a pretty silly mistake. That, to me, indicates a certain degree of carelessness, but not something to actively sound the alarms over.

What did bother me immensely was when I scrolled down to look at the comments. One reads:

"In any case, the way her torso appears to be shaved down is more problematic, no? In the pink photo, the same model looks believably (healthily) slim; in the blue, she's as stretched and skinny Olive Oyl. I worry far more about young women aspiring to extreme thinness as a standard of beauty than to amputation. (Or maybe I'm behind the curve, and that's the next trend.)"


Wait, what? I scrolled back up to look at the photos in question. In case you're feeling lazy this Friday morning, here's a side-by-side comparison.






I have to at least partially agree: the photos of this model-- who is clearly the same woman-- look significantly different. In blue, she appears to have a much longer, slimmer torso, and I don't know if that's necessarily because her shirt is untucked. I mean, this could just be the magic of angles and maybe she hasn't been stretched in the photo at left, but either way it got me thinking about the instances of Photoshop that I never seem to notice. As an adult woman in modern society, I do know that everything I see in any kind of media is Photoshopped, but sometimes when the cases aren't so terrible, they slip quietly under the radar. And for me, I think those subtle changes are what we really need to be worried about. It's easy to explain that perfectly poreless skin is the result of digital airbrushing. It's easy to notice the manipulations when you see a woman on the cover of a magazine looking slightly unlike herself and more like a plastic doll. But when the changes a just a slight stretch upward and a bit of torso-slimming, it's harder to catch and easier for those changes to infiltrate our body images.


Now, I have nothing against thin women. I get the sense that many times, in an effort to feel better about ourselves and to reject the truly awful things the media tries to do to us, we turn skinny people into villains working for The Man, and they're not. I think women of all shapes and sizes are beautiful in their own way-- even if their looks don't suit my personal beauty preferences as a straight woman. There certainly are women with long, very slender torsos, but I'm not exactly sure this model is one of them-- not to the degree she is in the left photo. And that's damaging no matter how close your body is to matching the aesthetic ideal. For me, the slight tweaks speak volumes:


You are not okay, you are not okay, you would be so pretty if, they intone. 


But let's talk.


What do you think about Photoshop? Are you good at spotting it? Do you think it influences your body image? Have you ever digitally manipulated a photo of yourself for Facebook, Myspace, etc.? Why or why not? And of course, do you think the above example is subtle Photoshop or a really flattering shirt/camera angle?

Monday, June 21, 2010

Let's Talk: Selling Out



I know it's no secret here that I'm planning on writing full time as a career. This is something I'm completely passionate about, but also something I struggle with as a consumer and analyzer of media. There's a lot I find discouraging about the world of magazines: broadly speaking, how many of them (including those for men) portray unhealthy, unobtainable ideals, subtly encourage self-loathing, and show a very narrow definition of what's "acceptable."

In my wildest dreams, I will be one of the writers out there railing against the system, writing articles about self-love and acceptance and deep, meaningful, truly important topics. In my wildest dreams, I will be one of the people who will change the game and show women that they don't have to settle for mediocre chick rags because they want and deserve more than that-- maybe if some more great, empowering stuff is out there and accessible in the mainstream, it'll change a lot of attitudes. (I'd also love to write for magazines that are targeted more at men, but most of you are women, thus the angle I'm taking here).

It's hard to deny, however, that to become successful in any business, you have to play their game to some extent-- and sometimes that may mean doing things that are contrary to our own morals and/or goals.

If I have to write about "Diet Tips for Sexier Sex!" at some point in my career to get to a point where I have to opportunity to really spread the message I want to spread, would that make me a sell-out? And is it even that bad to be a sell-out? We all need money to put food in our stomachs, clothing on our backs, and roofs over our heads. Sometimes ideals don't make the kind of money we need. And what then? Where do we make the compromises? Where do we stand strong? It's probably different for everyone, but I think it's a very real problem we face: to be able to change the game, we may first have to play it, and what then?*

Many people call that "selling out." But is it so bad?

This is something I've been thinking a lot about, and I decided the best way to bring it up here would be to have a discussion. Last time I did a "Let's Talk" post, it was very successful, and some of you mentioned to me that you'd like to see more discussion-- so here you go! I'm always really thrilled to hear what you have to say. I would love it if everyone could feel comfortable enough to be open about their own beliefs and experiences, so please try to be respectful of each other-- and feel free to be "anonymous" if it helps any. I'll be coming back to discuss (and I hope you'll all check back and chat amongst each other if you have the time) and moderate if necessary.

So what is "selling out" to you? Is there such a thing? Is it ever justified? Where would you draw the line between acceptable and not? Have you ever done something/been asked to do something that you felt was selling out? And if you did, could you tell us why you decided to do it or not? How do you feel about it looking back? Of course, any and all other thoughts related (even tangentially) to this topic are more than welcome.



*I have a friend who once told me she wants to go to law school and sell her soul to a big corporate firm for a few years so that she'll have the money to live while she dedicates her life to charity/volunteer work afterward.

Tuesday, May 25, 2010

Let's Talk: Co-Opting Words



The other day, when I was thinking about what I'd like to write about on le blog this week, I decided I wanted to discuss the word "fat." I've been doing a lot of body image talk in the past few months, and you guys have shown a lot of interest and support (and for that, I'm really grateful, just so you know). I've been trying-- dunno if anyone noticed-- to write something related to that topic every week. I don't want to sound like a broken record, though, and I've been hoping to think of different angles to tackle and all that.

That said, I'm an English major, which sort've implies I'm in an ongoing love affair with words. I love picking apart meanings and really thinking about the things we say, their implications, and their origins. I think language is endlessly fascinating and that, even if it's not your cup of tea, you can probably acknowledge it's pretty darn interesting.

"Fat" is the word I've been thinking about lately. After discovering the whole boundless world of plus-size lifestyle and fashion blogs, I began to use the word more freely-- even in context of myself. Though what everyone considers fat is very different, I see my body every day and feel it falls somewhere toward/on that end of the spectrum. Many larger bloggers out there today seem completely accepting of the word, even using it in blog titles (Young, Fat, & Fabulous, for example), without being judgey. In the plus-size blogging word, it seems that "fat" isn't as judgey as it can be out here in the "real" world. It's a word that can be used either with pride or as a simple acknowledgment of size, just as someone who call themselves "thin." Of course, the two words have two completely different connotations. Fat bad, thin good. You know the deal.

I was going to write about how I think the process of co-opting the word "fat" is incredibly positive... but then... well, I didn't know. Is it? Why not another, more P.C. word? And considering that I think co-opting hurtful racist or sexist language is usually incredibly harmful, what is it that makes this word so different?

So then I didn't know what I thought.

At my college, we have a lecture series called Difficult Dialogues, in which speakers come and discuss topics that people are often too uncomfortable to deal with. We've had speakers on Invisible Children, the conflict in the Middle East (Norman Finkelstein, after some scheduling issues, gave a lecture), and aspects of Black culture in American society, to name a few in very broad terms. I wanted to think of this post sort've like that, like a dialogue among me, you, and everyone else that reads and comments. I thought maybe we could exchange opinions, engage in-- respectful, please-- debate, and learn something from each other about a topic that's a bit controversial.

So shall we? Wanna? Let's go!


What do you think of co-opting words? Are there "negative" words that you use, positively, to refer to yourself? What do you think the boundaries are for co-opting? Are there any? I'd love to hear your thoughts!*


EDIT: Georgie brought up an interesting quote in the comments from Mean Girls: "You all have got to stop calling each other sluts and whores. It just makes it okay for guys to call you sluts and whores." This reminded me of an old news story that The Boondocks satirized (if you watch both clips, they basically copy it exactly) where a White teacher calls a Black student "nigga." While there's a lot that's WRONG about that (the teacher was obviously out of line), you can't ignore the logic he used: Black people who use the n-word tend to imply with an "-a" it's positive and with an "-er" it's bad... so why can't anyone say "nigga?" And if Black people don't like the word, why do they use it?

(Both clips NSFW due to language).




* As always, please be try to be respectful of one another. I'm all for differing opinions-- and I want to hear it all, don't be shy!-- but anything that seems to be blatantly hurtful will be deleted at my discretion.

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails